Editorial standards & methodology
How we know what we say.
Indophile is a knowledge platform, so its method is part of its content. These are the rules every entry is held to.
01
Every claim is traceable
Entries and their individual sections cite records in a shared bibliography. An entry with no sources cannot be published — the build fails.
02
Kinds of evidence stay separate
Archaeological evidence, inscriptions, later historical texts, oral traditions and mythology are distinguished. Traditional accounts are presented respectfully and labelled as traditions.
03
Nothing is invented
No dates, discoveries, genetic results, quotations, references or boundaries are created to fill a gap. Gaps are shown as gaps.
04
Borders come from published maps
Political boundaries are drawn exactly as published in Cliopatria (Seshat Global History Databank, Scientific Data 2025, CC BY 4.0). Indophile generates no borders of its own; polities without a published boundary appear only as their located capitals, inscriptions and monuments.
05
No retroactive nations
Modern borders appear only for orientation. Ancient polities are never described as belonging to present-day nation-states.
06
Neutrality
We avoid nationalist, religious, ethnic and political framing, and present competing scholarly positions in their own terms.
Evidence classification
Five levels of confidence
Applied to whole entries and to individual sections, so an established site can still carry a debated interpretation.
- Established
Supported by strong archaeological, textual or scientific evidence.
- Well supported
Supported by multiple credible sources; some details uncertain.
- Debated
Competing scholarly interpretations exist.
- Hypothesis
An interpretation requiring further evidence.
- Unverified
Insufficient evidence to support the claim.
Dating
Not every date is equal
Years are stored on a signed axis (BCE negative) with an explicit precision. Many events have no exact start or end — and the data model does not pretend otherwise.
- ●Secure date
- ◐Conventional date
- ○Approximate
- ◌Debated
- Secure date
- Fixed by independent evidence such as a dated inscription.
- Conventional date
- The date scholars use by convention; may rest on a single tradition.
- Approximate
- Estimated range — radiocarbon, stratigraphy or style.
- Debated
- Substantially different chronologies exist.
Archaeogenetics
Rules for writing about ancient DNA
- Genetic ancestry is never presented as equivalent to ethnic, linguistic, religious, caste or national identity.
- No present-day community is described as the direct, unchanged descendant of a single ancient population.
- Direct ancient-DNA evidence, statistical modelling and indirect inference are labelled separately on every study and concept.
- Ancestry proportions are not re-plotted or rounded by us; readers are sent to the study, where the model behind the number is explained.
Images
Every plate is credited
Photographs are drawn from openly licensed collections (currently Wikimedia Commons), each stored with its author, licence and source link and shown on every plate. We prefer photographs of actual sites and objects over reconstructions; when reconstructions are added they will be labelled as such, with their basis.
Status of this dataset
The current entries are a seed dataset prepared to demonstrate the platform's structure. Bibliographic records are drawn from standard works, but every record still requires verification by a subject editor before public launch. The editorial dashboard tracks this.