Skip to content
INDOPHILE

Ancient DNA

One Genome from Rakhigarhi: What It Can and Cannot Tell Us

In 2019 a team published the first genome from an Indus civilisation cemetery. The headlines were loud. The evidence is narrower — and more interesting — than either side claimed.

Period
c. 2800 – 2300 BCE(Approximate)
Location
◇ Haryana, and Indus-associated individuals in Iran and Central Asia
Reading time
8 min read
Author
Indophile Editorial
Evidence
Well supported
A burial in the Harappan cemetery at Rakhigarhi.
A burial in the Harappan cemetery at Rakhigarhi.Photo: Aadrit28 · CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons

From the Trenches

From the trenches

Established

What does the archaeological evidence reveal?

Ancient DNA survives poorly in the heat and monsoon humidity of South Asia. Of the skeletons sampled from the Rakhigarhi cemetery, the team obtained usable data from one individual, catalogued as I6113, buried in a Mature Harappan context.

SourcesShinde et al. 2019

What the DNA Says

What the DNA says

Well supported

What archaeogenetics can tell us — and its limits

The individual's ancestry matched a pattern previously seen in eleven people buried far away, at Gonur in Turkmenistan and Shahr-i Sokhta in Iran, who were genetically unlike their neighbours. Researchers had interpreted those eleven as migrants from the Indus world. Rakhigarhi provided a match from within it.

The genome was modelled as a mixture of ancestry related to ancient Iranian-plateau populations and to AASI. No steppe-related ancestry was detected — consistent with the view that steppe-related ancestry arrived in South Asia later, in the 2nd millennium BCE.

SourcesShinde et al. 2019; Narasimhan et al. 2019

What it cannot tell us

Established

One person cannot represent a civilisation of perhaps a million people across a million square kilometres. The genome tells us nothing about the language its owner spoke, or what she or anyone around her believed or called themselves.

Nor can it establish that any present-day group 'descends from' the Harappans and others do not. Every present-day South Asian population is the product of multiple histories of mixture.

SourcesNarasimhan et al. 2019

What We Still Don't Know

What we still don't know

Debated

Unresolved questions and competing interpretations

How genetically varied the Indus population was across its range; when the Iranian-related component first arrived in South Asia; and how the many unsampled regions fit the picture. More genomes — and more careful archaeological contexts — are needed.

SourcesShinde et al. 2019

Archaeological evidence

Sites, artefacts and events in this story

Sources & Further Reading

Sources & further reading

  1. journal articleShinde, V. et al. (2019). An Ancient Harappan Genome Lacks Ancestry from Steppe Pastoralists or Iranian Farmers. Cell 179(3): 729–735. doi:10.1016/j.cell.2019.08.048
  2. journal articleNarasimhan, V. M. et al. (2019). The formation of human populations in South and Central Asia. Science 365(6457): eaat7487. doi:10.1126/science.aat7487